Eden House vs Nearby Hotels
Considering Eden House but want to compare other hotels nearby? These guides show how Eden House stacks up against popular alternatives.
Updated · 19 comparisons
All 19 Eden House Comparisons

Eden House vs Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection
Compare Eden House’s intimate Old Town courtyard with Casa Marina’s beachfront Curio resort — small-boutique vs full-service beachfront.
Compare →
Eden House vs Ocean Key Resort & Spa
Eden House: small, garden-boutique with a heated pool; Ocean Key Resort & Spa: upscale waterfront at Mallory Square.
Compare →
Eden House vs Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa
Eden House: historic Old Town boutique with courtyard pool and Azur restaurant; Hyatt Centric: waterfront resort with marina, spa, and 120 rooms.
Compare →
Eden House vs Pier House Resort & Spa
Boutique garden hotel (Eden House) vs waterfront resort with spa and beach (Pier House) — both in Old Town Key West.
Compare →
Eden House vs The Reach Key West, Curio Collection
Eden House: small Old Town boutique with courtyard pool and Azur restaurant. The Reach Key West, Curio Collection: beachfront resort with full-service spa and private beach.
Compare →
Eden House vs Margaritaville Beach House Key West
Eden House: historic Old Town boutique with garden courtyards and a courtyard pool; Margaritaville Beach House Key West: beachfront, brand-driven resort with many suites.
Compare →
Eden House vs Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses
Eden House: historic Old Town boutique with courtyard pool and Azur Restaurant; Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses: larger Southernmost-area resort near oceanfront activity.
Compare →
Eden House vs The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Eden House: historic 18-room garden hotel; The Marker: modern harbor-side resort with 3 pools.
Compare →
Eden House vs Parrot Key Hotel & Villas
Eden House: small Old Town boutique with courtyard pool and Azur Restaurant. Parrot Key Hotel & Villas: resort-style cottages, multiple pools and water activities.
Compare →
Eden House vs Hilton Key West Resort & Marina
Eden House: historic Old Town boutique with courtyard pool and Azur restaurant. Hilton Key West Resort & Marina: large branded waterfront resort with a marina and six pools.
Compare →
Eden House vs La Concha Key West, Autograph Collection
Eden House: intimate Old Town garden hotel with a heated courtyard pool; La Concha: larger Autograph Collection hotel right on Duval Street.
Compare →
Eden House vs Havana Cabana at Key West
Eden House: small Old Town boutique with courtyard pools and Azur Restaurant; Havana Cabana: retro-themed New Town resort with a lively pool scene.
Compare →
Eden House vs DoubleTree Resort
Eden House — historic Old Town boutique with courtyard pool; DoubleTree Resort — branded beachfront resort with conference space.
Compare →
Eden House vs Ocean Key Resort A Noble House Resort
Garden boutique with Azur Restaurant and heated courtyard pool vs waterfront Noble House resort with spa and sunset views.
Compare →
Eden House vs Santa Maria Suites
Eden House: historic boutique with Mediterranean dining and heated pool; Santa Maria Suites: upscale all-suite resort-style near southern Key West beaches.
Compare →
Eden House vs The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Eden House: historic Old Town courtyard hotel with Azur Restaurant and heated pool. The Perry: modern marina resort on Stock Island with docks, two pools and waterfront dining.
Compare →
Eden House vs Southernmost House Adult Exclusive
Eden House: Old Town garden hotel with Azur and a heated pool; Southernmost House - Adult Exclusive: adults-only oceanfront mansion steps from Southernmost Point.
Compare →
Eden House vs H2O Suites
Eden House: historic courtyard hotel with heated pools and Azur restaurant; H2O Suites: adults-only luxury suites near Duval.
Compare →
Eden House vs The Gardens Hotel
Eden House: small historic Old Town hotel with heated pool, Tiki Bar happy hour and Azur restaurant. The Gardens Hotel: elegant garden stay with two pools and refined rooms.
Compare →
Mediterranean meals & poolside happy hour
- Lowest rate guarantee
- Complimentary perks & upgrades
- 24/7 concierge