
Eden House
Best for travelers who want a small, locally run Old Town hotel with intimate gardens, a heated pool and easy walking access to Duval Street.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Eden House is a locally owned, small Old Town Key West boutique set around tropical courtyards, pool, Jacuzzi and a Mediterranean restaurant—good for travelers who want a compact, garden-style Key West stay. The Reach Key West, Curio Collection is a Hilton-affiliated beachfront resort with a full-service spa, one on-site restaurant and private beach—read this if you prefer beachfront access and a polished resort experience.
Updated

Best for travelers who want a small, locally run Old Town hotel with intimate gardens, a heated pool and easy walking access to Duval Street.

Best for guests who want a beachfront resort with a full-service spa, meeting space and on-site resort amenities under a major brand.
When Eden House wins: choose Eden House if you want a small, historic, locally owned property with a courtyard pool, poolside Tiki Bar and Mediterranean restaurant within Old Town walking distance of Duval Street and the seaport.
When The Reach wins: pick The Reach Key West, Curio Collection if a private beach, a larger pool footprint, a branded full-service spa and formal meeting or event space matter to you, or if you prefer the predictability of a Hilton Curio property.
Bottom line: both suit visitors who want to be in Old Town Key West; Eden House is the smaller, more intimate local option, while The Reach is the beachfront, full-service alternative with more rooms and resort amenities.
| Category | Eden House | The Reach Key West, Curio Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, locally owned boutique with tropical courtyards and a relaxed pool area | Polished beachfront Curio Collection resort with full-service facilities |
| Location | Old Town/ Historic District near Duval Street and the seaport | Old Town Key West, on a private beach and close to Simonton/ Duval area |
| Size | 18 rooms | 150 rooms |
| Ages / audience | All-ages property (primary guest must be 25+ to check in) | All-ages (not adults-only) |
| Pools & beach | Heated outdoor pool, hot tub/Jacuzzi, two pool areas and poolside Tiki Bar | Outdoor pool(s) plus private on-site beach and a poolside bar |
| Restaurants & bars | Azur Restaurant (Mediterranean) + Tiki Bar poolside | Four Marlins restaurant + poolside bar and room service (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | Spa & wellness area with sauna and massages; fitness center on-site | Full-service spa with treatment rooms and a fitness center |
| Events & meeting space | Outdoor Tropical Garden Venue; accommodates weddings (up to 120) and property buyouts | Conference space and 4 meeting rooms (about 4,700 sq ft / 437 m²) |
| Known for | Historic 1924 property, intimate garden weddings and Old Town feel | Private beach access and branded resort services (Hilton Curio Collection) |
| Wi‑Fi & extras | Complimentary Wi‑Fi throughout property; complimentary lobby coffee/tea | Wireless internet (surcharge) and multilingual staff; express check-out |
Eden House sits in Old Town Key West near Duval Street and the historic seaport.
Choose Eden House for an Old Town base focused on walking, biking and nearby bars, restaurants and galleries.
The Reach places you on a private stretch of Key West shoreline while still within reach of Old Town.
Choose The Reach when beachfront access and a resort setting matter but you still want Old Town within walking distance.
Eden House keeps the room set small and local with 8 room types across 18 rooms.
Eden House is best if you want a small, characterful room selection and an intimate property footprint.
The Reach offers a broad inventory of individually decorated guestrooms and suites across about 150 rooms.
The Reach works if you want more room variety, ocean-view upgrades and accessibility options within a branded resort.
Eden House centers dining around Azur Restaurant and a poolside Tiki Bar.
Eden House suits guests who prefer an intimate on-site restaurant and casual pool-bar culture in a boutique setting.
The Reach provides resort-style dining with Four Marlins plus poolside and in-room options.
The Reach is a better fit when you want a hotel restaurant, room service and straightforward resort dining options.
Eden House is organized around tropical courtyards with heated pools and a hot tub.
Pick Eden House for courtyard pool time and a quiet, garden-focused pool scene.
The Reach combines an outdoor pool with direct access to a private beach.
Choose The Reach if a hotel beach and broader water-activity options matter to your stay.
Eden House offers spa/wellness options alongside Old Town nightlife a short walk away.
Eden House blends in-house wellness with easy access to Old Town nightlife and evening walks.
The Reach emphasizes a full-service spa and resort-formal pampering.
The Reach is the choice if on-site spa treatments and resort programming are priorities.

Eden House—small scale, garden courtyards, heated pool and Azur restaurant put you in Old Town steps from Duval.

The Reach—private beach plus resort amenities give you ocean access without leaving the property.

The Reach—full-service spa, treatment rooms and larger fitness offerings under a branded program.

Eden House—historic gardens and a Tropical Garden Venue tailored to intimate and buyout weddings (up to 120 guests).
Both are in Old Town Key West and within walking distance of Duval Street; Eden House emphasizes very short walks to Duval and the seaport while The Reach combines beach access with walkability to Old Town.
No. The Reach Key West, Curio Collection is not an adults-only property.
The Reach Key West, Curio Collection has a private beach; Eden House does not have on-site beach access.
Yes—Eden House is all-ages, though the primary guest checking in must be at least 25 years old.
The Reach is set up for meetings and events with about 4,700 sq ft (437 m²) of conference space and multiple meeting rooms; Eden House is much smaller and has limited room inventory.
Explore how Eden House stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·