
Eden House
Best for travelers who want a compact, characterful Old Town stay within easy walking distance of Duval Street and the Historic Seaport.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Eden House is a small, independently owned boutique hotel in Old Town Key West built around tropical courtyards, a heated pool, and an on-site Mediterranean restaurant — read this if you want an intimate, walkable Old Town base. Hilton Key West Resort & Marina is a major branded waterfront resort with an on-site marina and multiple pools — read this if you prefer full-service resort facilities and marina access.
Updated · about 4.5 mi apart

Best for travelers who want a compact, characterful Old Town stay within easy walking distance of Duval Street and the Historic Seaport.

Best for guests who want a recognizable full-service brand with extensive pool options, marina access, and on-site water activities.
When Eden House wins: choose Eden House when you want a small, historic property in Old Town with an intimate courtyard pool, Azur restaurant, daily complimentary lobby coffee, bikes to explore, and easy walking access to Duval Street and the seaport.
When Hilton Key West Resort & Marina wins: pick the Hilton if you want a larger resort experience with many rooms (about 175), multiple outdoor pools (6), marina and on-site water activities, and the consistency of a major brand for meetings or marina-related plans.
Bottom line: Eden House is about atmosphere, location, and small‑hotel service in the heart of Old Town; Hilton Key West Resort & Marina is about scale, waterfront/mooring access and resort amenities. Your choice depends on whether walkable Old Town charm or branded marina/resort facilities matter more.
| Category | Eden House | Hilton Key West Resort & Marina |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, historic boutique in Old Town; courtyard and garden focus | Large, branded waterfront resort and marina hotel |
| Location | 1015 Fleming St — walkable to Duval Street and the Historic Seaport | 5950 Peninsular Avenue — waterfront/near Stock Island Yacht Club & Marina |
| Size (guest rooms) | 18 rooms | About 175 guestrooms |
| Ages / family policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must be 25+ to check in | |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool, hot tub/Jacuzzi; two pool areas reported | Six outdoor pools |
| Restaurants & bars | Azur Restaurant (Mediterranean) + poolside Tiki Bar (daily happy hour) | One restaurant, one bar, and a poolside bar; cooked-to-order breakfast available (fee) |
| Spa & wellness | Spa & wellness centre offering massages, sauna and hot tub; fitness centre on site | 24-hour fitness facilities and yoga classes/instruction on site; spa details Not published |
| Known for | Historic 1924 property, intimate garden weddings, Old Town walkability | Marina, water activities (boat tours, kayaking, personal motorized watercraft), resort pool options |
| Parking & transport | Limited on-site parking (first-come); bikes available; car not recommended in Old Town | Self parking (surcharge); RV/bus/truck parking (surcharge); ferry/boat access to nearby waters |
| Event capacity / groups | Garden wedding venue up to 120 guests; whole-property buyout available but only 18 rooms | Meeting rooms and meeting capacity available (meeting rooms listed) |
Eden House sits at 1015 Fleming St in Old Town within easy walking distance of Duval Street, the Historic Seaport, and many attractions.
Pick Eden House for maximum Old Town convenience and a compact location for sightseeing on foot or by bike.
Hilton Key West Resort & Marina is located on Peninsular Avenue next to Stock Island Yacht Club & Marina, oriented toward waterfront access.
Choose the Hilton when you prioritize marina access and watersports over being in the heart of Old Town.
Eden House has 18 individually named rooms and suites with characterful layouts.
Eden House offers charm and handful of distinct room types; it’s best for travelers who value character over scale.
Hilton Key West Resort & Marina lists about 175 guestrooms across many room types, including ocean- and partial-ocean-view options and suites.
Hilton offers many room categories and suites, suitable for travelers who want predictable, accessible options at scale.
Eden House centers on Azur Restaurant plus the poolside Tiki Bar for meals and casual drinks.
Eden House suits travelers who want on-site, locally styled dining in an intimate setting.
Hilton has one main restaurant, a bar, and a poolside bar with cooked-to-order breakfast available for a fee.
The Hilton provides bigger resort dining flow and poolside service, useful when you prefer on-site convenience over options tied to a small property.
Eden House focuses on a heated outdoor courtyard pool, hot tub/Jacuzzi, sundeck and a Tiki Bar.
Eden House’s pool areas emphasize relaxed courtyard time rather than wide resort options.
Hilton Key West Resort & Marina highlights resort-scale water amenities and an on-site marina.
Hilton is the choice for guests who plan to spend time on multiple pools and take advantage of marina activity access.
Eden House provides a small spa/wellness area, a sauna and in-room or on-site massage options plus easy access to Old Town nightlife.
Eden House pairs light on-site wellness services with immediate Old Town nightlife access.
Hilton lists 24-hour fitness facilities, yoga classes/instruction, and extensive tour/activity support tied to marina services.
Hilton supports active and marine-focused itineraries with formal fitness options; Old Town nightlife is less walkable.

Eden House — steps from Duval Street, the Historic Seaport, and major Old Town sights.

Hilton Key West Resort & Marina — on-site marina with boat tours, kayaking and personal motorized watercraft.

Eden House — garden venue for up to 120 guests and a whole-property buyout option, with an historic setting.

Hilton Key West Resort & Marina — multiple pools (6) and many room types to suit larger parties.
Eden House is significantly closer — it’s within easy walking distance to Duval Street; Hilton Key West Resort & Marina is on the waterfront near Stock Island and requires transport to reach Old Town.
The supplier listing identifies the Hilton as a waterfront property with an on-site marina; it does not explicitly say 'beachfront.'
Hilton Key West Resort & Marina is better if you want on-site marina services, boat tours, kayaking and personal motorized watercraft. Eden House can arrange local excursions via its concierge but does not have an on-site marina.
No — neither Eden House nor Hilton Key West Resort & Marina is an adults-only property; both welcome guests of all ages (Eden House requires the primary guest to be 25+ to check in).
Explore how Eden House stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·