
Eden House
Best for travelers who want a small, Old Town base with character, garden wedding options, and easy walkability to Duval Street.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Eden House is a locally owned, historic boutique in Old Town Key West centered on tropical courtyards, a heated pool, and an on-site Mediterranean restaurant—read this if you want a small, characterful hotel within easy walking reach of Duval Street. Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa is a four-star branded waterfront resort with a marina, full spa, and larger resort amenities—read this if you prefer a full-service resort with dock access and spa services.
Updated · about 0.3 miles (roughly 0.5 km) apart

Best for travelers who want a small, Old Town base with character, garden wedding options, and easy walkability to Duval Street.

Best for guests who want a waterfront resort with marina access, an on-site full-service spa, and more extensive fitness and meeting facilities.
When Eden House wins: choose Eden House if you want a small, locally owned property with Old Town character, a heated courtyard pool and Tiki Bar, Azur Mediterranean dining on site, and an intimate wedding venue. Its compact scale (18 rooms) and garden setting suit couples and families who value atmosphere and walkability.
When Hyatt Centric wins: choose Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa if you want branded resort conveniences—about 120 rooms, a dock/marina, a full-service spa with treatment rooms, 24-hour fitness options, and on-site meeting spaces—plus a pool and direct waterfront access close to Duval Street and the seaport.
Bottom line: Eden House is the choice for a boutique Old Town experience and small-event wedding buyers; Hyatt Centric is the choice for travelers seeking a waterfront resort with spa services and marina energy while still being centrally located.
| Category | Eden House | Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, locally owned boutique focused on courtyard gardens and a relaxed poolside scene. | Branded waterfront resort with marina energy, resort amenities, and a spa. |
| Location | Old Town Fleming Street—walking distance to Duval Street, Historic Seaport, and the Key West Express ferry terminal. | Front Street on the waterfront—steps from Florida Keys Beaches, Duval Street, Key West Bight Marina and Mallory Square. |
| Size | 18 rooms (small, intimate). | 120 rooms (larger resort scale). |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; primary registering guest must be at least 25 to check in. | All ages welcome; standard hotel minimums apply (not an adults-only property). |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool(s), hot tub/Jacuzzi, two pool areas and a poolside Tiki Bar; some sources note pool access may be limited or require advance contact. | One outdoor pool with sun loungers and poolside bar; waterfront walkway and marina access. |
| Restaurants & bars | Azur Restaurant (Mediterranean) and the Tiki Bar (daily happy hour); Azur serves breakfast, lunch, dinner. | Four Flamingos Key West (American, ocean-view) plus a poolside bar and lounge; room service available (limited hours). |
| Spa & wellness | Spa and wellness area with sauna and massage options; some services are in-room per listings. | Full-service spa with treatment rooms plus a 24-hour fitness center, fitness classes, and wellness offerings. |
| Known for | Historic 1924 property, garden wedding venue and small-group buyouts; Old Town character. | Waterfront location, marina/dock, branded service level and larger meeting/event spaces. |
| Accessibility & family features | No elevators; limited onsite parking; free Wi‑Fi; complimentary coffee/tea 24 hours; children welcome (policy requires 25+ registering guest). | Elevators and multiple accessible room types listed; self parking (surcharge), free Wi‑Fi, concierge, and family room configurations available. |
| Event spaces | Outdoor Tropical Garden Venue for weddings (up to 120); full-property buyout option available. | Meeting rooms and banquet/meeting facilities; wedding services and event support available. |
Eden House sits on Fleming Street in Old Town Key West inside the historic district, a short walk to Duval Street and the seaport.
Choose Eden House to be in the heart of Old Town in a quieter garden setting a short walk from Key West’s main attractions.
Hyatt Centric is on Front Street at the waterfront and places you steps from the seaport, Duval Street, and Mallory Square.
Choose Hyatt Centric if you want waterfront access and proximity to marina departures while remaining central to Old Town.
Eden House offers eight room types across 18 rooms, many with courtyard views and a boutique layout.
Eden House’s rooms emphasize Old Town charm and courtyard access rather than resort-scale inventories.
Hyatt Centric lists about 120 air-conditioned rooms and a long list of room types and accessible options.
Hyatt Centric provides more room variety, ocean-view options, and accessibility features for a broader range of needs.
Eden House’s on-site dining focuses on Azur Restaurant and the courtyard Tiki Bar.
Eden House keeps dining local and relaxed with one full restaurant and a lively pool bar in the courtyard.
Hyatt Centric features Four Flamingos Key West with ocean views plus a pool bar and lounge options.
Hyatt Centric’s dining suits guests who want waterfront dining and resort-style bar choices with more formal service options.
Eden House centers guest life around heated courtyard pools, a Jacuzzi/hot tub, and a Tiki Bar.
Eden House’s pools are intimate, tucked into the garden courtyard—great for quiet pool time close to your room.
Hyatt Centric offers a single outdoor pool and direct walkways to the water and marina slips.
Hyatt Centric is the pick for guests who want a waterfront resort experience and easy access to boats and marina services.
Eden House provides spa and wellness offerings, a fitness center, and a nearby Old Town nightlife scene within walking distance.
Eden House pairs a modest on-site wellness setup with direct access to Old Town’s evening scene.
Hyatt Centric offers a full-service spa, 24-hour fitness center, and on-property fitness classes.
Hyatt Centric is stronger for guests prioritizing a full spa and round-the-clock fitness options while staying near waterfront nightlife.

Eden House — historic 1924 property, tropical gardens, and an outdoor wedding venue with a full-property buyout option.

Hyatt Centric — dock/marina on site and a waterfront location steps from the seaport and Mallory Square.

Hyatt Centric — full-service spa with treatment rooms and a 24-hour fitness center with classes.

Eden House — just 18 rooms, a heated courtyard pool, and a relaxed, locally owned atmosphere.
Both are within easy walking distance of Duval Street; Eden House sits on Fleming Street in Old Town while Hyatt Centric is on Front Street at the waterfront, both central to attractions.
Hyatt Centric has a full-service spa with treatment rooms and a 24-hour fitness center; Eden House offers spa services, a sauna and massages but on a smaller, boutique scale.
Yes. Eden House advertises an outdoor Tropical Garden Venue (up to 120 guests) and offers whole-property buyouts. Hyatt Centric also provides wedding services and meeting spaces but is a larger resort venue.
Yes. Both properties welcome guests of all ages. Eden House requires the primary registering guest to be at least 25 to check in; Hyatt Centric is not adults-only.
Explore how Eden House stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·