
Eden House
Best for travelers who want Old Town proximity, a quiet courtyard pool, and a small boutique feel.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Eden House is a small, historic Old Town boutique (18 rooms) with quiet courtyards, a heated pool, Tiki Bar and Mediterranean restaurant — read this if you want walkable access to Duval Street and a low-key Old Town base. Havana Cabana at Key West is a larger, retro Cuban–styled resort in New Town with a louder pool scene and 106 individually decorated rooms — read this if you prefer a resort pool vibe and on-site resort amenities.
Updated · about 2.3 miles apart

Best for travelers who want Old Town proximity, a quiet courtyard pool, and a small boutique feel.

Best for guests who want a bigger, resort-style pool and a lively, themed atmosphere.
When Eden House wins: pick Eden House if you want to stay in Old Town within easy walking distance of Duval Street, museums and the seaport, if you value a small property (18 rooms) and quieter courtyard pools, or if a historic boutique setting matters.
When Havana Cabana at Key West wins: choose Havana Cabana if you prefer a larger resort-style hotel with a prominent pool scene, onsite snack bar and poolside bar, more room-type variety, and easier car parking.
Bottom line: Eden House is the choice for Old Town intimacy and short walks to main attractions; Havana Cabana is the choice for a retro-themed, pool-focused stay farther from Old Town.
| Category | Eden House | Havana Cabana at Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Quiet, historic Old Town boutique with tropical courtyards and intimate pool areas. | Retro Cuban–themed, resort-style hotel centered on a large, social pool scene. |
| Location | 1015 Fleming St — in Old Town, walkable to Duval Street, seaport and cultural sites. | 3420 N. Roosevelt Blvd — in New Town, farther from Old Town attractions. |
| Size (rooms) | 18 rooms | 106 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All-ages property; primary guest must meet the hotel's 25+ check-in policy. | All-ages (not adults-only); family-friendly room types listed. |
| Pools & hot tubs | Heated outdoor pool(s), Jacuzzi/hot tub in a tropical courtyard; two on-site pool areas listed. | One outdoor pool and one hot tub; large resort-style pool scene with poolside bar. |
| Restaurants & bars | Azur Restaurant (Mediterranean) + poolside Tiki Bar with daily happy hour. | Floridita Food Truck / snack bar-deli + bar/lounge and a poolside bar; cooked-to-order breakfast available (surcharge). |
| Spa & wellness | Spa & wellness area with sauna, in-room massages and fitness centre listed. | Complimentary use of a nearby fitness center; on-site hot tub. Spa branding or full spa service not published. |
| Known for | Historic 1924 property, garden wedding venue and Old Town walkability. | Distinctive retro Cuban theme and an active pool bar scene. |
| Parking & transport | Limited on-site parking (first-come), cars not recommended for Old Town; bicycle rentals available. | Free self parking on site and electric car charging station listed. |
| Check-in / check-out | Check-in begins at 4:00 PM; check-out 9:30–10:00 AM; primary guest must be 25+ to register. | Check-in window 4:00 PM–midnight listed; check-out 11:00 AM. |
Eden House sits in Old Town, putting Duval Street, the historic seaport and cultural sites within walking distance.
Choose Eden House if you want short walks to Old Town attractions and a compact, pedestrian-friendly base.
Havana Cabana is located in New Town, offering more on-site space but farther from Old Town attractions.
Pick Havana Cabana if you want more on-site resort space and easier parking, and don’t mind being outside the Old Town core.
Eden House has a very small roster of room types focused on suites and island rooms.
Eden House suits travelers who prefer a small, intimate hotel with a limited number of thoughtfully curated room types.
Havana Cabana lists a wide variety of room types and configurations across 106 guestrooms.
Havana Cabana fits travelers who want more choice in room layout, accessible options, and poolside room categories.
Eden House offers on-site Mediterranean dining plus a poolside Tiki Bar with daily happy hour.
Eden House provides a fuller sit-down restaurant experience in addition to a relaxed pool bar in a courtyard setting.
Havana Cabana leans on casual, pool-facing food and drink with a snack bar and poolside bar.
Havana Cabana is geared toward casual, poolside eating and drinking rather than a formal restaurant program.
Eden House centers guest life around tropical courtyards with heated pools and a Jacuzzi.
Eden House’s pools are quieter, courtyard-focused and complement the small-hotel atmosphere.
Havana Cabana emphasizes a larger resort-style pool and an active poolside bar.
Havana Cabana’s pool is the property’s social hub and appeals to guests focused on pool time and atmosphere.
Eden House provides a modest spa/wellness offering and easy access to Old Town nightlife.
Eden House combines basic on-site wellness options with immediate access to Old Town nightlife.
Havana Cabana relies on its on-site pool scene and nearby New Town options for evening activity.
Havana Cabana centers evening socializing around its pool and bar rather than Old Town walking nightlife.

Eden House — walking distance to Duval Street, Mallory Square and the seaport.

Havana Cabana — larger resort pool and a louder poolside atmosphere.

Eden House — historic tropical gardens and an outdoor wedding venue (capacity up to 120) with a full-property buyout option.

Havana Cabana — free self parking on site and many room types, including pool-view and premium balcony options.
Eden House is in Old Town and within walking distance of Duval Street; Havana Cabana is in New Town and a few miles from Old Town.
Havana Cabana is positioned around a resort-style pool scene; Eden House’s pools are quieter courtyard pools with a Tiki Bar.
No — both properties welcome guests of all ages (neither is adults-only).
Eden House — because it’s inside Old Town with immediate walking access to restaurants and nightlife on Duval Street.
Yes — supplier listing shows a resort fee and a service fee collected at the property.
Explore how Eden House stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·