
Eden House
Best for guests who want a social courtyard, a heated pool and a daily happy hour at a poolside Tiki Bar.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Eden House is an all-ages historic boutique hotel in Old Town Key West built around tropical courtyards, a heated pool, Jacuzzi and a lively poolside Tiki Bar. The Gardens Hotel is an elegant, garden-focused boutique property near Duval Street that suits travelers wanting a refined, quiet stay — read this if you’re choosing between a casual courtyard vibe and a more formal garden retreat.
Updated

Best for guests who want a social courtyard, a heated pool and a daily happy hour at a poolside Tiki Bar.

Best for travelers seeking an elegant, garden-refined stay close to Duval Street with two outdoor pools and Tempur-Pedic beds.
When Eden House wins: pick Eden House if you want a smaller, more casual Old Town stay with a lively pool courtyard, an on-site Mediterranean restaurant (Azur), complimentary daily happy hour and easy bike access around Key West. It’s also the better option for on-property garden weddings and group buyouts where a compact, intimate venue matters.
When The Gardens Hotel wins: choose The Gardens Hotel if you prefer a quieter, more formal garden setting, slightly larger property scale, two outdoor pools, and rooms that emphasize luxury finishes like Tempur-Pedic beds and private furnished balconies.
Bottom line: both are historic, garden-style boutique hotels in Old Town Key West. If courtyard social time, a Tiki Bar happy hour and a very small-property feel are priorities, go with Eden House; if you want a polished garden retreat with multiple pools and a refined vibe, The Gardens Hotel is the better match.
| Category | Eden House | The Gardens Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, casual courtyard with social poolside Tiki Bar and Mediterranean restaurant. | Elegant, garden-refined boutique near Duval Street with a quiet, polished feel. |
| Location (Old Town) | 1015 Fleming St, within easy walking distance of Duval Street and the Historic Seaport. | 526 Angela Street, centrally located in Old Town and steps from Duval Street. |
| Size (rooms) | 18 rooms on property. | 21 rooms on property. |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must be 25+ to check in (spring-break rules apply). | Adults-only property (guests under 16 are not permitted per supplier listing). |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool, Jacuzzi/hot tub and a courtyard setting; two pool areas reported. | Two outdoor pools and poolside bar; pool sun-loungers and umbrellas available. |
| Restaurants & bars | Azur Restaurant (Mediterranean) + poolside Tiki Bar with complimentary daily happy hour. | On-site restaurant and 2 bars/lounges, plus a poolside bar; complimentary cooked-to-order breakfast. |
| Wellness / spa | On-site spa & wellness area (Jacuzzi, hot tub, sauna) and in-room massages noted; fitness center on site. | Health/beauty spa nearby (supplier listing) and general concierge for bookings. |
| Known for | Garden wedding venue, intimate buyouts, lively courtyard happy hour. | Refined garden grounds and proximity to Duval Street; high guest rating (9.8). |
| Accessibility & family features | No elevators; not wheelchair accessible; children welcome; no pets allowed. | Wheelchair-accessible public washroom and accessible path of travel listed; some accessible rooms and parking. |
| Parking & arrival | Limited on-site parking (first-come), street parking and nearby garage options; car not required. | Self parking available (surcharge), secured parking and uncovered parking listed. |
Eden House sits in Old Town Key West close to Duval Street and the Historic Seaport.
Choose Eden House for a true Old Town location where walking and biking are practical ways to explore.
The Gardens Hotel is centrally located in Old Town, a short walk from Duval Street and local attractions.
Choose The Gardens Hotel if you want a refined garden stay that keeps Duval Street within very easy walking reach.
Eden House has 18 rooms in a mix of suites and island-style rooms across a compact property.
Eden House suits travelers seeking a small-property, historic room inventory with courtyard access.
The Gardens Hotel offers 21 air-conditioned rooms and suites with Tempur-Pedic beds and private furnished balconies or patios.
The Gardens Hotel is for travelers who want slightly larger room choices and upgraded sleep / bath features.
Eden House is home to Azur Restaurant and the poolside Tiki Bar (daily happy hour).
Eden House fits travelers who want an onsite casual restaurant plus a social pool bar scene.
The Gardens Hotel lists one on-site restaurant plus two bars/lounges and a poolside bar.
The Gardens Hotel leans toward polished, garden-side dining and quieter bar spaces rather than a party atmosphere.
Eden House centers around a heated outdoor pool, Jacuzzi and a tropical courtyard used for social hours and events.
If you want a lively pool courtyard and evening social time on-site, Eden House delivers that experience.
The Gardens Hotel lists two outdoor pools and poolside service suited to relaxed garden stays.
The Gardens Hotel offers multiple pool spaces for a more tranquil, garden-focused pool experience.
Eden House has a spa & wellness area, fitness center, and a courtyard that doubles as an evening gathering spot.
Eden House mixes on-site wellness with an easy walk to the island’s nightlife and excursions.
The Gardens Hotel emphasizes a calm garden environment with nearby health/beauty spa options listed.
Pick The Gardens Hotel if you want quieter garden evenings and access to nearby spa services arranged by concierge.

Eden House — small-property buyouts, outdoor garden ceremony spaces and capacity for up to 120 guests make it ideal for intimate-to-medium weddings.

The Gardens Hotel — adults-only policy and a polished garden setting suit couples who prefer a quieter, more formal atmosphere.

Eden House — heated courtyard pool, Jacuzzi and a daily complimentary Tiki Bar happy hour make the property a social hub.

The Gardens Hotel — centrally located with very short walks to Duval Street attractions and nearby museums.
Eden House is family-friendly and welcomes children of any age (the primary guest must meet the 25+ check-in rule). The Gardens Hotel is listed as an adults-only property that does not permit guests under 16.
Eden House — it has a poolside Tiki Bar with a complimentary daily happy hour and a courtyard that functions as a social space.
No. Neither property is all-inclusive; The Gardens Hotel includes a complimentary cooked-to-order breakfast, while Eden House has an on-site restaurant (Azur) and complimentary lobby coffee/tea but room rates don’t include all meals.
The Gardens Hotel lists accessible rooms, wheelchair-accessible paths and a pool hoist; Eden House has no elevators and is not wheelchair accessible.
Explore how Eden House stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·