
Eden House
Best for couples and small groups who want a quiet, garden-centered boutique stay close to Old Town attractions.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Eden House is a small, historic boutique hotel in Old Town Key West built around tropical courtyards and a heated pool — a good fit for travelers who want a garden-focused, intimate stay close to Duval Street. The Marker Key West Harbor Resort is a newer, modern harbor-side resort in the Historic Seaport area — read this if you want a larger property with multiple pools, direct seaport access, and more on-site services.
Updated · about 0.5 km apart

Best for couples and small groups who want a quiet, garden-centered boutique stay close to Old Town attractions.

Best for travelers who want a larger, service-rich hotel with multiple pools and immediate access to the Historic Seaport and marina.
When Eden House wins: choose Eden House if you want a small-property, historic vibe with tropical gardens, a single heated pool and a poolside Tiki Bar, plus easy bike access for exploring Old Town on a compact footprint.
When The Marker wins: choose The Marker Key West Harbor Resort if you prefer contemporary rooms with private balconies, more on-site amenities (including three outdoor pools), closer access to the marina and seaport activities, and a larger resort feel.
Bottom line: Eden House is the pick for a quieter, characterful Old Town stay and small events/weddings; The Marker is the pick for guests who want a modern harbor-side property with more pools and on-site services.
| Category | Eden House | The Marker Key West Harbor Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, small-boutique, garden-focused | Contemporary, larger resort, harbor-side |
| Location | Old Town Historic District, courtyard setting near Duval Street | Historic Seaport/Key West Bight marina, directly on the harbor |
| Size | 18 rooms | 96 rooms |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must be 25+ to check in | All ages welcome; supplier listing shows general adult policy (min age 21 to check-in on some channels) |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool plus hot tub/Jacuzzi (two pool areas reported) | Three outdoor pools |
| Restaurants & bars | Azur Restaurant (Mediterranean) + Tiki Bar (poolside) with daily happy hour | Starboard (poolside restaurant) + poolside bar; room service during limited hours |
| Spa & wellness | Spa & wellness area with sauna, massages; in-room massages reported | Not published |
| Known for | Garden weddings, historic 1924 property, intimate courtyard setting | Marina/seaport location, modern rooms with balconies, multiple pools |
| Accessibility & services | No elevators; not wheelchair accessible; limited parking; bike rentals | Elevator, wheelchair-accessible facilities, limited paid self-parking, bike rentals on site |
| Nearby highlights | Within easy walk to Duval Street, Key West Bight, Hemingway Home | |
Eden House sits in Old Town Key West around tropical courtyards and garden spaces, a short walk from Duval Street.
Stay here for an Old Town, garden-centered location that feels tucked away but is still within walking distance of the main sights.
The Marker is positioned on the Key West Historic Seaport at the marina, giving direct seaport access and harbor views.
Choose The Marker if you want immediate access to marina activities and a harbor-side base in Old Town.
Eden House offers a small set of room types centered on suites and island-style rooms in historic buildings.
Eden House suits travelers who prioritize character, garden views and a compact property over a large inventory of room types.
The Marker offers many room types, several with private balconies and harbor or pool views.
The Marker is the better choice if you want more room options, balconies, and rooms with direct harbor or pool views.
Eden House centers dining around Azur Restaurant and its poolside Tiki Bar.
Eden House delivers a single on-site restaurant plus a lively pool bar in a courtyard setting.
The Marker provides on-site dining at Starboard and poolside bar service, with room service available during limited hours.
The Marker offers a contemporary poolside dining option and more in-house food-service capacity than a very small boutique.
Eden House centers guest life around a heated courtyard pool, hot tub and Tiki Bar.
Eden House’s pool area is intimate and garden-focused — a social courtyard atmosphere rather than a large resort pool complex.
The Marker lists three outdoor pools and poolside dining and bar service.
The Marker’s multiple pools suit guests who prioritize swimming options and poolside dining at a larger resort.
Eden House offers spa and wellness services alongside a relaxed Old Town nightlife access.
Eden House pairs a small wellness offering with immediate access to Old Town’s bars and entertainment.
The Marker provides fitness facilities and positions you near evening activity on the waterfront and Duval Street.
The Marker is good for guests who want a fitness facility and easy access to seaport nightlife and boat-based evening options.

Eden House — its 18-room, 1924 property and tropical courtyards suit travelers who prefer a boutique, historic experience.

The Marker — located on the Historic Seaport/Key West Bight for easy access to boat tours and marina departures.

The Marker — lists three outdoor pools and more on-site amenities for guests who want pool variety.

Eden House — marketed as a garden wedding venue and offering a Tropical Garden Venue with outdoor-only ceremonies.
Both welcome children. Eden House is small and garden-focused, which can be convenient for families who want a compact property; The Marker has more rooms and pools, which can suit families wanting more on-site activity options.
The Marker sits adjacent to Key West Bight and the Historic Seaport, placing it nearest to many boat departure points; Eden House is a short walk away but not immediately on the marina.
No. Eden House is not all-inclusive; The Marker’s listing shows breakfast is available for a fee.
The Marker is not listed as adults-only (supplier listing marks adultsOnly as false) and is a harbor-side/marina resort. It is located on the seaport rather than being a traditional beachfront resort.
Explore how Eden House stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·