
Eden House
Best for couples and small groups who want a compact, historic boutique stay with a courtyard pool and on-site Mediterranean dining.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Eden House is a small, historic boutique hotel in Old Town Key West built around tropical courtyards and a heated pool — good for travelers who want a compact, character-filled stay close to Duval Street. Santa Maria Suites is an upscale, all-suite resort-style property near the southern end of Key West — ideal for travelers who want roomy suites, multiple pools, and easy access to beaches and Duval Street.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for couples and small groups who want a compact, historic boutique stay with a courtyard pool and on-site Mediterranean dining.

Best for families or groups who want larger suite layouts, kitchens, and multiple outdoor pools near South Beach and Duval Street.
When Eden House wins: If you want a small, historic hotel with intimate courtyard gardens, a heated pool/Jacuzzi, a Mediterranean restaurant (Azur) and a lively poolside Tiki Bar happy hour in a boutique setting, Eden House is the better fit.
When Santa Maria Suites wins: If you prefer spacious two-bedroom suites or villa-style rooms with kitchens, multiple outdoor pools, on-site bike rentals and a location very close to Southernmost Point and Simonton/South Beach, Santa Maria Suites is the practical choice.
Bottom line: Choose Eden House for historic character, intimate grounds and on-site Azur dining; choose Santa Maria Suites for larger suite layouts, more pool space and proximity to southern Key West beaches and attractions.
| Category | Eden House | Santa Maria Suites |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, boutique, garden courtyard | Upscale, all-suite, resort-style |
| Location (Old Town) | Fleming St in Old Town (1015 Fleming St), short walk to Duval Street | Simonton St near Duval Street and South Beach (1401 Simonton St); steps from Duval |
| Size | 18 rooms | 35 guestrooms |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must be 25+ to check in | All ages welcome; no adults-only policy published |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool(s), Jacuzzi/hot tub; two pool areas listed | Two outdoor pools, poolside bar |
| Restaurants & bars | Azur Restaurant (Mediterranean) + Tiki Bar (daily happy hour) | Onlywood Grill (on-site restaurant) + bar and poolside bar; daily reception |
| Spa / wellness | Spa & wellness area with sauna, massage options and in-room massages | Not published |
| Rooms & layouts | Boutique rooms and suites (8 room types) — smaller, character rooms | Multiple two-bedroom bi-level and flat suites; kitchens in guestrooms |
| Known for | Historic 1924 property, garden weddings, intimate Old Town setting | Upscale all-suite resort-style stays near southern Key West beaches |
| Practicalities | Limited on-site parking (first-come), no elevators, non-smoking, no pets | Limited parking (self parking surcharge), free Wi‑Fi, concierge, wheelchair-accessible path/parking |
Eden House sits on Fleming Street in Old Town Key West within easy walking range of Duval Street and the historic seaport.
Choose Eden House if you want a central Old Town base with historic character a short walk from Duval Street.
Santa Maria Suites is on Simonton Street near the southern end of Old Town, steps from Duval Street and close to South Beach and Southernmost Point.
Choose Santa Maria Suites for very close access to southern Old Town beaches and Southernmost Point while staying near Duval Street.
Eden House offers 8 room types across 18 rooms, favoring boutique layouts and courtyard views.
Pick Eden House if you want a smaller hotel with character rooms and easy access to the courtyard pool and Azur Restaurant.
Santa Maria Suites focuses on larger suite-style accommodations, including many two-bedroom layouts.
Pick Santa Maria Suites if you need larger suites or apartment-style rooms with kitchens for family or multi-person stays.
Eden House’s on-site dining centers on Azur Restaurant plus a poolside Tiki Bar for drinks.
Eden House suits travelers who want on-site Mediterranean dining and a lively poolside bar in a small-hotel setting.
Santa Maria Suites offers an on-site restaurant, a bar and a daily complimentary reception for guests.
Santa Maria Suites is a good pick if you want suite living plus a resort-style mix of restaurant, bar and daily reception.
Eden House centers around tropical courtyards with heated pools, a Jacuzzi and poolside lounging.
Choose Eden House for an intimate, heated courtyard pool experience in a garden setting.
Santa Maria Suites features two outdoor pools and poolside amenities geared to suite guests.
Choose Santa Maria Suites if you prefer multiple larger outdoor pools as part of a resort-style stay.
Eden House provides a small spa/wellness program and places you within walking distance of Old Town nightlife.
Eden House pairs modest spa/wellness services with immediate Old Town access for evening plans.
Santa Maria Suites lists fitness facilities and concierge services; a dedicated spa facility is not published.
Santa Maria Suites provides fitness and activity support, though a named on-site spa is not published.

Eden House — historic 1924 building, tropical gardens, intimate pool courtyard and Azur Restaurant.

Santa Maria Suites — multiple two-bedroom suites and in-room kitchens for family-style stays.

Eden House — garden wedding venue and whole-property buyout options (up to 120 guests).

Santa Maria Suites — two outdoor pools and a location steps from South Beach and Southernmost Point.
Both accept children. Santa Maria Suites has larger two-bedroom suites and kitchens that often suit families better; Eden House welcomes families but has smaller room inventory (18 rooms).
Santa Maria Suites is highlighted as steps from Southernmost Point and South Beach; Eden House is in Old Town and within walking distance but a bit farther inland.
Yes. Eden House has Azur Restaurant and the poolside Tiki Bar; Santa Maria Suites has Onlywood Grill, a bar and a poolside bar plus a complimentary daily reception.
Eden House advertises a heated outdoor pool and Jacuzzi and two pool areas; Santa Maria Suites lists two outdoor pools but heating is not specified.
Explore how Eden House stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·