
Eden House
Best for travelers who want an intimate Old Town base, walkable access to Duval Street, and a garden wedding venue.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Eden House is a small, locally owned boutique hotel in Old Town Key West centered on tropical gardens and a courtyard pool — good for travelers who want walkable access to Duval Street and an intimate, historic stay. Margaritaville Beach House Key West is a larger, casual beach-house resort tied to the Margaritaville brand — read this if you want a beachfront, resort-style stay with chain-brand recognition.
Updated

Best for travelers who want an intimate Old Town base, walkable access to Duval Street, and a garden wedding venue.

Best for guests who prefer a beachside resort vibe, larger room choice, and a recognizable branded experience near Smathers Beach.
When Eden House wins: choose Eden House if you want a small, historic Old Town property with lush courtyards, an on-site Mediterranean restaurant (Azur), a heated courtyard pool with a Tiki Bar, and a quiet, intimate feel for couples or small families.
When Margaritaville Beach House Key West wins: pick Margaritaville Beach House Key West if you want beachfront proximity, many room types and suites, a bigger pool and resort-style amenities, a 24-hour fitness center, and complimentary airport shuttle on request.
Bottom line: Eden House is the Old Town boutique pick for walkable sightseeing, garden weddings and a quieter courtyard experience; Margaritaville Beach House Key West is the beach-facing, Margaritaville-branded option with more rooms, more resort amenities, and a straightforward beach-resort energy.
| Category | Eden House | Margaritaville Beach House Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small historic boutique in Old Town with tropical gardens and courtyard pool | Casual, family-friendly Margaritaville beach-house resort |
| Location | Fleming St, walking distance to Duval Street and the Historic Seaport | 2001 South Roosevelt Blvd, by the ocean near Smathers Beach |
| Size | 18 rooms | 186 rooms |
| Who can stay | All ages welcome; primary guest must meet the property's 25+ check-in policy | All ages welcome (supplier listing shows adultsOnly: false) |
| Pools & hot tubs | Heated outdoor courtyard pool, hot tub/Jacuzzi; two pool areas noted in listings | Outdoor pool, poolside bar, hot tub (listing shows 1 hot tub and 1 outdoor pool) |
| Restaurants & bars | Azur Restaurant (Mediterranean) + poolside Tiki Bar with daily happy hour | On-site restaurant with room service (limited hours) + bar/lounge and poolside bar |
| Spa & wellness | Spa & wellness area offering massages, sauna; fitness centre available | 24-hour fitness facilities; spa/health services nearby but no branded spa name listed |
| Family & accessibility | Family-friendly but no elevators and limited accessibility; no pets allowed | Family-friendly with multiple accessibility features listed (wheelchair accessible paths, pool hoist, accessible rooms) |
| Airport transfer | No airport shuttle provided (guests typically use taxi or rideshare) | Complimentary roundtrip airport shuttle available on request |
| Known for | Historic 1924 property, tropical garden weddings and Old Town walkability | Beachfront location and Margaritaville brand recognition |
Eden House sits in Old Town's Historic District and is within easy walking distance of Duval Street and the seaport.
Choose Eden House for immediate Old Town access and short walks to key landmarks.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West is located on South Roosevelt Boulevard beside the ocean and near Smathers Beach.
Choose Margaritaville Beach House Key West if beachside location and ocean access matter most.
Eden House is a small property with eight room types focused on comfort and Old Town character.
Eden House keeps inventory small and characterful — good for couples and small families needing fewer rooms.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West offers many room and suite configurations across a much larger inventory.
Margaritaville gives a wide range of room types and accessible options for families and groups.
Eden House features Azur Restaurant and a poolside Tiki Bar for straightforward, Mediterranean-forward dining and casual drinks.
Eden House is restaurant-forward for a small property — Mediterranean meals and poolside drinks are on-site and easy.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West has an on-site restaurant, bar/lounge and poolside bar with room service during limited hours.
Margaritaville’s food-and-drink options fit the resort model, with multiple on-site outlets and poolside service.
Eden House centers guest life around its heated courtyard pool, a hot tub/Jacuzzi, and a poolside Tiki Bar.
Eden House offers a quiet courtyard-pool experience that complements an Old Town stay.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West provides a traditional resort pool experience plus direct ocean access nearby.
Margaritaville matches its beachfront location with a standard resort pool setup and on-site pool service.
Eden House emphasizes spa and relaxation with a small wellness area and immediate Old Town nightlife within walking distance.
Eden House is suitable for guests who want a short walk to Old Town nightlife plus a small on-site spa.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West lists 24-hour fitness facilities and nearby health/beauty spas, fitting a more active resort stay.
Margaritaville is set up for active days and beachside recreation, with a full-service fitness center and access to watersports.

Eden House — steps from Duval Street, the Historic Seaport and Old Town attractions.

Margaritaville Beach House Key West — located on South Roosevelt Blvd beside the ocean and near Smathers Beach.

Margaritaville Beach House Key West — 186 rooms and many suite configurations including 2-bedroom suites.

Eden House — garden wedding venue with outdoor capacity for up to 120 guests and whole-property buyout options.
Eden House — it’s in Old Town and within easy walking distance of Duval Street and the seaport.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West — it’s located beside the ocean near Smathers Beach.
Yes. Both welcome families, though Eden House has a 25+ primary check-in policy and limited room inventory, while Margaritaville lists many family-friendly room types.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West lists a complimentary roundtrip airport shuttle on request; Eden House does not provide an airport shuttle.
Explore how Eden House stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·