
Eden House
Best for Old Town walks, small weddings, and courtyard pool time in a historic setting.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Eden House is a small, historic Old Town boutique hotel set around tropical courtyards and a heated pool—good for travelers who want walkable access to Duval Street and a garden-wedding venue. The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a modern, marina-focused resort on Stock Island with contemporary nautical styling—best for travelers seeking on-water activities and marina access.
Updated

Best for Old Town walks, small weddings, and courtyard pool time in a historic setting.

Best for boating, marina access, and a contemporary resort feel with multiple pools.
When Eden House wins: Choose Eden House if you want to stay in the heart of Old Town Key West, be within easy walking distance of Duval Street and the historic seaport, prefer a small property with a courtyard pool and Mediterranean dining, or need a garden venue for a wedding or full-property buyout.
When The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West wins: Choose The Perry for a marina-focused, activity-forward stay with on-site dock/marina features, two outdoor pools, a 24-hour fitness center, and easy access to boat tours, fishing, and water sports departures from Stock Island.
Bottom line: Eden House delivers Old Town character, small size (18 rooms) and garden/courtyard vibes; The Perry is a larger, contemporary marina resort focused on boating and pool amenities. Pick Old Town convenience and historic atmosphere (Eden House) or a marina-and-activity base on Stock Island (The Perry).
| Category | Eden House | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Old Town courtyard hotel with Mediterranean restaurant and Tiki Bar | Contemporary nautical boutique resort centered on a working marina |
| Location | 1015 Fleming St, inside Key West Historic District — walkable to Duval Street and the seaport | 7001 Shrimp Road, Stock Island — waterfront, on-site marina |
| Size (rooms) | 18 rooms | 100 guestrooms (supplier listing) |
| Who can stay / ages | All ages welcome; primary guest must be 25 to check in | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool, plus a hot tub/Jacuzzi; two pool areas listed in sources | Two outdoor pools; poolside bars |
| Restaurants & bars | Azur Restaurant (Mediterranean) + Tiki Bar with daily happy hour | Two restaurants (including Matt's Stock Island) and 2 bars + 2 pool bars |
| Spa & wellness | Spa & wellness area with sauna, massages and in-room massage service options | Not published |
| Known for | Historic garden weddings, courtyard setting, proximity to Old Town attractions | Marina facilities, boating and on-site docking, water-sports access |
| Accessibility & parking | No elevators; limited on-site parking (first-come), not pet-friendly | Self parking (surcharge); multilingual staff and 24-hour front desk |
| Wi‑Fi & basics | Free Wi‑Fi, complimentary lobby coffee/tea, bicycle rentals | Free Wi‑Fi, concierge, gift shops/newsstand, 24-hour fitness center |
Eden House sits in Old Town Key West, a short walk from Duval Street and the historic seaport.
Eden House is the better pick if staying inside Old Town on foot or by bike matters.
The Perry is on Stock Island, positioned around a working marina and waterfront activities.
The Perry suits travelers focused on boating, fishing and direct marina access.
Eden House is an intimate hotel with 18 individually named rooms and suites.
Expect compact, characterful rooms and fewer total options at Eden House.
The Perry offers many more guestrooms and a wider range of layouts.
The Perry provides more room variety and more accessible/poolside options.
Eden House centers its food and drink around Azur Restaurant and a poolside Tiki Bar.
Eden House is for guests who want relaxed Mediterranean meals and a courtyard bar atmosphere.
The Perry has multiple on-site dining options with an emphasis on seafood and waterfront dining.
The Perry offers more on-site dining and bar choices, including waterfront seafood options.
Eden House’s courtyard is its signature — heated pool, Jacuzzi and a Tiki Bar in a tropical garden.
Eden House’s courtyard pool and garden are the heart of the guest experience.
The Perry emphasizes waterfront activities and has two outdoor pools and dock access.
The Perry is better for guests who want multiple pools and direct marina/water access.
Eden House offers a small spa/wellness area and a lively garden/pool bar for evenings.
Eden House mixes low-key wellness services with courtyard nightlife via the Tiki Bar.
The Perry provides a 24-hour fitness center and activity desk for water-sport bookings.
The Perry is more activity- and fitness-oriented, with services for arranging marina excursions.

Eden House — steps from Duval Street, Mallory Square and the historic seaport.

The Perry — on-site marina, dock services and many water-sport options.

Eden House — historic gardens, tropical courtyard and a whole-property buyout option; capacity noted up to 120 guests for ceremonies.

The Perry — two restaurants, multiple bars and two outdoor pools for broader on-site choices.
Eden House is located in Old Town and is the closer choice for walking to Duval Street, Mallory Square and the historic seaport.
The Perry is the better base for fishing, boat tours and water-sport departures thanks to its on-site marina and dock facilities.
No. Both Eden House and The Perry welcome guests of all ages; Eden House requires the primary guest checking in to be at least 25 years old.
The Perry has many more guestrooms (about 100) and a wider set of on-site amenities; Eden House is a small 18-room boutique property focused on its courtyard and garden setting.
Explore how Eden House stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·