
Eden House
Best for travelers who want a small, garden-focused Old Town property with a relaxed poolside scene and an on-site Mediterranean restaurant.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Eden House is an 18-room, locally owned boutique hotel in Old Town Key West built around tropical courtyards and a heated pool — read this if you want a relaxed, garden-centered stay near Duval. Ocean Key Resort & Spa is an upscale waterfront resort at the Mallory Square end of Duval Street with a full spa and harbor views — read this if you want a sunset‑side, waterfront location and resort amenities.
Updated · about 1.1 miles (≈1.8 km) apart

Best for travelers who want a small, garden-focused Old Town property with a relaxed poolside scene and an on-site Mediterranean restaurant.

Best for travelers who want an upscale, waterfront stay at Mallory Square with a full spa, harbor views, and easy access to sunset activity.
When Eden House wins: Choose Eden House if you prefer a small-property, courtyard setting, a heated pool/Jacuzzi and a laid-back poolside Tiki Bar within easy walking distance of Old Town attractions and bicycle-friendly streets.
When Ocean Key Resort & Spa wins: Choose Ocean Key if you want to be right at Mallory Square for the nightly sunset activity, prefer waterfront rooms and comprehensive resort services (spa, fitness center, concierge, water-sports desk).
Bottom line: Both are solid Old Town options; Eden House is the smaller, garden-boutique pick for a quieter, intimate stay, while Ocean Key is the larger, amenity-rich waterfront choice for travelers prioritizing location on the harbor and resort-style services.
| Category | Eden House | Ocean Key Resort & Spa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, garden-centered boutique with tropical courtyards and relaxed pool life | Upscale, active waterfront resort focused on harbor views and sunset activity |
| Location | Fleming Street in Old Town; walkable to Duval and the Historic Seaport | Zero Duval at the Mallory Square end of Duval Street, on the waterfront |
| Size (rooms) | 18 rooms | Not published |
| Ages / policy | All-ages property; primary registrant must be at least 25 to check in | All ages (not adults-only); general minimum check-in age 18 listed on some sites |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool, hot tub/Jacuzzi; two pool areas reported | Outdoor and indoor pool(s) listed plus poolside bar |
| Restaurants & bars | Azur Restaurant (Mediterranean) + poolside Tiki Bar (daily happy hour) | On-site restaurants and bars; restaurant breakfast and poolside bar listed |
| Spa & wellness | Spa/wellness area with sauna, in-room massages available and fitness center | Full spa, massage services and a fitness center / yoga room |
| Known for | Historic, garden wedding venue and intimate Old Town experience | Prime Mallory Square waterfront location and sunset views |
| Accessibility & family features | No elevators; not wheelchair accessible; children welcome; limited parking | Wheelchair accessible; daily housekeeping; family-friendly |
| Safety & health | Property follows standard safety/housekeeping procedures (hotel policies listed) | Extensive COVID-era and sanitization measures listed (masks, daily disinfection, room seal after sanitization) |
Eden House sits on Fleming Street in Key West’s Old Town Historic District, a short walk to Duval Street and the seaport.
Eden House places you inside Old Town's quieter lanes with easy pedestrian access to attractions.
Ocean Key Resort & Spa sits at Zero Duval on the Mallory Square waterfront — the heart of Key West’s sunset activity.
Ocean Key puts waterfront and sunset action literally outside the resort; great if you want to be center-stage for Mallory Square.
Eden House is a small property with 18 rooms and several suite and island-room options arranged around gardens.
Expect intimate, individually styled rooms centered on courtyard views rather than large, uniform towers.
Ocean Key offers a mix of harbor-view and land-view room options, including SUITE OCEAN VIEW and Junior Suite Land View.
Ocean Key focuses on waterfront rooms and resort amenities; pick ocean-view categories if the harbor matters to you.
Eden House’s on-site dining centers on Azur Restaurant plus a poolside Tiki Bar for drinks and happy hour.
Eden House provides approachable, Mediterranean-focused dining in a courtyard setting.
Ocean Key lists on-site restaurants, bars and a poolside bar; breakfast service and bar happy-hour features are noted in the listing.
Ocean Key offers multiple on-site dining outlets and full-service options suited to a waterfront resort stay.
Eden House centers social life around its heated outdoor pool, a hot tub/Jacuzzi and a poolside Tiki Bar in the courtyard.
If you want a relaxed pool courtyard to spend afternoons, Eden House is set up for that.
Ocean Key lists outdoor and indoor pool options and a poolside bar as part of its waterfront resort amenities.
Ocean Key provides resort-style pools paired with direct access to harbor activities and sunset viewing.
Eden House offers basic wellness amenities and quiet evening options centered around the garden and bar.
Eden House balances low-key evening options with access to Key West nightlife a short walk away.
Ocean Key includes a full spa, massage services, fitness facilities and an on-site team for tours and water sports.
Ocean Key is a resort choice for travelers who want a full-service spa and on-site activity bookings at a waterfront address.

Eden House — 18 rooms, courtyard pools and a garden wedding venue make it the quieter, boutique pick.

Ocean Key Resort & Spa — located at Mallory Square with harbor-view rooms and immediate sunset access.

Ocean Key Resort & Spa — full spa, massage services, fitness center and yoga room are listed.

Eden House — Azur Restaurant serves Mediterranean breakfast, lunch and dinner on a shaded terrace.
Ocean Key is directly at the Mallory Square end of Duval Street; Eden House is about 1.1 miles away on Fleming Street.
No. Eden House and Ocean Key Resort & Spa welcome guests of all ages; Eden House does require the primary registrant to be at least 25 to check in.
Eden House markets a tropical garden wedding venue (outdoor ceremonies, up to 120 guests) and offers whole-property buyouts; Ocean Key may host events but Eden House explicitly promotes garden weddings.
Yes. Eden House lists a spa/wellness area (sauna, in-room massages) and Ocean Key lists a full spa with massage services.
Explore how Eden House stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·