
Eden House
Best for couples or small groups who want a quiet, courtyard-centered Key West stay within easy walking distance of Duval Street.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Eden House is a small, locally owned boutique hotel in Old Town Key West built around tropical courtyards — read this if you want an intimate, walkable Key West base with a courtyard pool and Mediterranean dining. Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection is a larger, full-service historic beachfront resort in the Curio Collection by Hilton — read this if you want a beachfront property with bigger-scale amenities, meeting space and a branded luxury experience.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for couples or small groups who want a quiet, courtyard-centered Key West stay within easy walking distance of Duval Street.

Best for travelers who want an oceanfront resort with multiple pools, a full-service spa and larger meeting/banquet facilities.
When Eden House wins: choose Eden House if you prioritize a small, historic property with a heated courtyard pool, a poolside Tiki Bar with daily happy hour, and a compact, walkable Old Town location. Its 18 rooms, Mediterranean restaurant (Azur) and garden wedding options suit travelers who prefer a low-key, local-owned experience.
When Casa Marina wins: choose Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection if you want private beach access, multiple outdoor pools, a larger selection of room types (including oceanfront suites and lofts), an on-site full-service spa and significant meeting or event space. It’s suited to guests who want resort-scale amenities and beachfront access under a Hilton brand.
Bottom line: Eden House is the intimate, historic choice for Old Town exploration and relaxed courtyard time; Casa Marina is the larger, beachfront Curio resort for travelers wanting resort amenities, two pools, a spa and private beach.
| Category | Eden House | Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Intimate, courtyard-centered boutique with tropical gardens | Grand historic beachfront resort with polished, larger-scale service |
| Location | Old Town Key West, short walk to Duval Street and the Historic Seaport | Old Town Key West on the beach (Higgs/Florida Keys Beaches), about a kilometer from Duval |
| Size | 18 rooms | 311 rooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must meet 25+ check-in policy | All ages welcome (not adults-only); standard hotel policies apply |
| Pools & beach | Heated outdoor courtyard pool, hot tub/Jacuzzi; two pool areas noted in some listings | Two outdoor pools and private beach access |
| Restaurants & bars | Azur Restaurant (Mediterranean) + Tiki Bar poolside happy hour | Morrison’s Market (restaurant/market) + bar/lounge + beach bar; room service limited hours |
| Spa & wellness | Spa/wellness area offering massages, sauna and in-room treatments; fitness center on-site | Full-service spa and fitness facilities |
| Known for | Historic 1924 property, garden weddings, quiet Old Town setting | Historic beachfront location and large meeting/banquet space under Hilton’s Curio brand |
| Meeting & event space | Garden wedding venue (outdoor) with capacity up to 120; no large conference rooms published | About 976 sq meters (10,504 sq ft) of conference space across 7 meeting rooms |
| Wi‑Fi & connectivity | Complimentary Wi‑Fi throughout property | Free WiFi in public areas; in-room wireless internet may have surcharge per supplier listing |
Eden House sits in Old Town Key West’s historic district, close to Duval Street and the seaport.
Choose Eden House for the most walkable Old Town experience and easy access to historic attractions.
Casa Marina is on Key West’s ocean side with private beach access and proximity to Higgs Beach.
Choose Casa Marina if beachfront access and ocean views matter most.
Eden House is small (18 rooms) with room types that emphasize suites and island-style rooms.
Eden House suits travelers who want boutique room choices and courtyard access rather than a large inventory of suites.
Casa Marina offers a broad variety of rooms and suites including oceanfront and accessible options.
Casa Marina provides more room types, including larger oceanfront suites and accessible rooms for varied needs.
Eden House’s dining centers on Azur Restaurant plus a lively poolside Tiki Bar.
Eden House focuses on a single onsite restaurant and a social pool bar in a relaxed setting.
Casa Marina provides a mix of casual and resort dining, including a market-style restaurant and beach bar.
Casa Marina offers more on-site dining variety and a beachfront bar for daytime beach service.
Eden House centers on a heated courtyard pool, hot tub and tiki-bar social area.
Eden House’s courtyard pool and Tiki Bar create a private, social resort feel in a boutique scale.
Casa Marina offers resort-scale outdoor recreation with two pools and a private beach.
Casa Marina is the choice for guests who want beach access plus multiple pool options at a single property.
Eden House provides basic wellness options and easy access to Old Town nightlife.
Eden House combines modest on-site wellness with immediate access to Old Town evening options.
Casa Marina includes a full-service spa and fitness facilities alongside on-site entertainment options.
Casa Marina gives you a hotel spa and fitness program without leaving the property, plus beachfront evening options.

Eden House — small (18 rooms), courtyard pools and a local-owned, historic atmosphere.

Casa Marina — private beach, beach loungers and on-site water activities.

Casa Marina — large conference space (about 10,504 sq ft) and seven meeting rooms.

Casa Marina — multiple food/beverage outlets (Morrison’s Market, beach bar, cafe, deli and room service).
Eden House is located in Old Town within a short walk of Duval Street; Casa Marina is beachside and about a kilometer from the central Duval corridor.
No. Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection is not an adults-only property; it welcomes guests of all ages.
No. Eden House is an Old Town, courtyard-centered property without private beachfront rooms; for a beach stay choose Casa Marina.
Casa Marina has multiple outdoor pools plus a private beach; Eden House focuses on a heated courtyard pool and hot tub in a more intimate setting.
Explore how Eden House stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·