
Eden House
Best for families and garden-focused stays near Old Town attractions and for travelers who want Mediterranean dining onsite.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Eden House is an Old Town Key West boutique hotel built around tropical gardens, heated pools, and a Mediterranean restaurant — good for families and travelers who want a garden-and-pool stay within walking range of Duval Street. Southernmost House - Adult Exclusive is an adults-only historic oceanfront mansion with ocean-view rooms and a seaside café — aimed at adults who want an oceanfront, boutique Key West experience.
Updated · about 1.0 mi apart

Best for families and garden-focused stays near Old Town attractions and for travelers who want Mediterranean dining onsite.

Best for adults seeking an oceanfront boutique stay steps from Southernmost Point and Duval Street.
When Eden House wins: choose Eden House if you want an all-ages property with tropical gardens, a heated pool and hot tub, on-site Mediterranean dining (Azur) and a lively poolside Tiki Bar with daily happy hour — good for families, weddings, and guests who prioritize a courtyard setting in Old Town.
When Southernmost House - Adult Exclusive wins: choose Southernmost House if you want true oceanfront location, ocean-view rooms or bungalows, and an adults-only environment within a short walk of Southernmost Point and Duval Street.
Bottom line: both are small, historic Key West properties with similar boutique scale and walkable access to Old Town. Pick Eden House for gardened courtyard charm, family use and on-site Mediterranean dining; pick Southernmost House - Adult Exclusive for beachfront views and an adults-only atmosphere.
| Category | Eden House | Southernmost House Adult Exclusive |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Old Town garden hotel with courtyard pools and relaxed Mediterranean dining | Victorian oceanfront mansion converted to an adults-only boutique resort-style inn |
| Location | 1015 Fleming St — Old Town, short walk to Duval and the seaport | 1400 Duval St — oceanfront, steps from Southernmost Point and South Beach |
| Size (rooms) | 18 rooms | |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must be 25+ to check in | Adults-only property (children 18 and younger not permitted) |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool(s) plus hot tub/Jacuzzi and poolside Tiki Bar | One outdoor pool; ocean access and terrace seating |
| Restaurants & bars | Azur Restaurant (Mediterranean) + poolside Tiki Bar with daily happy hour | Seaside Cafe at Mansion with ocean views; 1 bar/lounge listed |
| Spa & wellness | Spa/wellness area, sauna, massages and in-room massage options | Not published |
| Accessibility & parking | No elevators; limited on-site parking (first-come); bikes available | Self parking (surcharge); front desk limited hours; wheelchair accessible noted on listing |
| Known for | Tropical gardens, courtyard wedding venue and a heated pool with Tiki Bar | Iconic mansion setting, ocean views and proximity to Southernmost Point |
| Breakfast | On-site Azur serves breakfast; complimentary lobby coffee/tea 24 hours | Complimentary continental breakfast daily (Seaside Cafe hours listed) |
Eden House sits on Fleming Street in Old Town, within easy walking distance of Duval Street, the historic seaport and several museums.
Pick Eden House for a quiet Old Town garden feel while staying close to bars, restaurants and the seaport.
Southernmost House - Adult Exclusive sits at 1400 Duval Street right by Southernmost Point, offering oceanfront proximity and easy access to South Beach.
Choose Southernmost House if being on the waterfront and close to Southernmost Point is a priority.
Eden House offers a mix of compact rooms and suites clustered around garden courtyards.
Eden House works well for families or groups needing modest suites and courtyard access.
Southernmost House provides adults-only room types that emphasize ocean or courtyard views and bungalow options with kitchenettes.
Southernmost House is aimed at adults who prioritize ocean views or small-suite comforts like kitchenettes.
Eden House has on-site Mediterranean dining and a poolside bar that hosts a daily happy hour.
Eden House is a better single-property option if you want a full-service restaurant plus a lively pool bar on site.
Southernmost House features Seaside Cafe at Mansion with ocean views and a bar/lounge for guests.
Southernmost House suits adults wanting beachside café dining and easy access to nearby Duval restaurants.
Eden House centers on courtyard pool areas with a heated pool, hot tub/Jacuzzi and poolside seating.
Eden House is ideal if you want pool-and-garden lounging rather than ocean swimming at the hotel.
Southernmost House is an oceanfront property with a terrace and one outdoor pool plus immediate access to South Beach.
Southernmost House is better if being on the water and having oceanfront views is more important than garden-pool seclusion.
Eden House offers spa services, a sauna and an active daily happy hour at the Tiki Bar.
Eden House blends simple spa services with an on-site social spot for evenings at the pool.
Southernmost House focuses more on oceanfront relaxation; a formal spa name or on-site spa services are not published in the supplier listing.
If you need a published spa program, Eden House has clearer spa offerings; Southernmost House emphasizes oceanfront relaxation instead.

Eden House — children of any age are welcome and the property offers family-friendly rooms and courtyard pool areas.

Southernmost House - Adult Exclusive — oceanfront rooms and terraces put you steps from the water and Southernmost Point.

Eden House — Azur Restaurant plus a lively poolside Tiki Bar cover full meals and casual drinks without leaving the property.

Southernmost House - Adult Exclusive — children under 18 are not permitted; the property is marketed and operated as adults-only.
Southernmost House is essentially at Southernmost Point and South Beach; Eden House is in Old Town about a mile away.
Eden House welcomes children of any age (primary guest must be 25+). Southernmost House - Adult Exclusive does not permit children 18 and younger.
Southernmost House lists several room types with kitchenettes (e.g., Pool View Bungalow Queen with Kitchenette, Premium Ocean View Bungalow King with Kitchenette, and a 1-Bedroom Suite with Full Kitchen). Eden House rooms do not list kitchenettes among the standard room types.
Eden House advertises a spa & wellness area with sauna and massage options (including in-room massage). Southernmost House's supplier listing does not publish a dedicated on-site spa.
Explore how Eden House stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·