
Eden House
Best for travelers who want a historic, social Key West stay around courtyards, a heated pool, and an on-site Mediterranean restaurant.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Eden House is a small, historic boutique hotel in Old Town Key West set around tropical courtyards and a heated pool—good for families, couples, and wedding groups who want a social, garden-centered stay. H2O Suites is an adults-only luxury suites property near Duval Street with a high-end boutique resort feel—best for couples and adults seeking a quieter, more polished suite experience.
Updated

Best for travelers who want a historic, social Key West stay around courtyards, a heated pool, and an on-site Mediterranean restaurant.

Best for adults or couples who want suite-style rooms, a quiet adults-only atmosphere, and a compact high-end boutique property steps from Duval Street.
When Eden House wins: Choose Eden House if you want a small, historic property with tropical gardens, a heated outdoor pool and hot tub, an on-site full-service restaurant (Azur), a lively poolside Tiki Bar with daily happy hour, and family-friendly policies—also useful if you’re planning a garden wedding or small group event.
When H2O Suites wins: Choose H2O Suites if you’re an adult or couple seeking an adults-only setting, suite layouts (including options like Deluxe Suite, 1 King Bed, Personal Plunge Pool), a rooftop terrace and fitness center, and a location literally a few steps from Duval Street and Key West’s Old Town attractions.
Bottom line: Both properties put you in Old Town Key West within easy reach of Duval Street, but Eden House is historic, social, and garden-focused with on-site dining and event capabilities; H2O Suites is a compact adults-only, suite-focused alternative for travelers who want a quieter, higher-end boutique stay near the action.
| Category | Eden House | H2O Suites |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic boutique, courtyard-focused, social | Adults-only luxury suites, boutique resort feel |
| Location (Old Town) | 1015 Fleming St—within Old Town walking area to Duval and seaport | 1212 Simonton Street—steps from Duval Street and close to South Beach |
| Size (rooms) | 18 rooms | 22 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must be 25+ to check in | Adults-only; guests under 25 not permitted |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool(s) plus hot tub/Jacuzzi; two pool areas | One outdoor pool; poolside bar and sun loungers |
| Restaurants & bars | Azur Restaurant (Mediterranean) + Tiki Bar (daily happy hour) | Bar/lounge and poolside bar; no full on-site restaurant published |
| Spa & wellness | Spa & wellness area with sauna, massages, in-room treatments | Not published |
| Known for | Historic 1924 property, tropical garden weddings, hands-on concierge | Adults-only suites, boutique luxury near Duval Street |
| Accessibility & services | No elevators; limited on-site parking; free Wi‑Fi; bike rentals | Elevator; self parking (surcharge); 24-hour front desk; concierge |
| Nearby highlights | Walking access to Duval, Hemingway Home, Key West Bight/Seaport | Steps from Duval Street, Key West Butterfly & Nature Conservatory, South Beach |
Eden House sits in Old Town Key West at 1015 Fleming St, within easy walking distance of Duval Street and the historic seaport.
A good base for sightseeing in Old Town with walkable access to Key West’s main attractions.
H2O Suites is at 1212 Simonton Street, a few steps from Duval Street and very close to South Beach and the Butterfly Conservatory.
Ideal if you want to be right by Duval Street while staying in a quieter, adults-only property.
Eden House offers eight room types across 18 rooms, mixing cottage and suite layouts around its courtyards.
Choose Eden House for variety and the courtyard/historic character; plan if stairs are an issue.
H2O Suites focuses on suite-style rooms; many list private balconies and some offer personal plunge pools.
Pick H2O Suites if you prefer suite layouts or want an option with a private plunge pool and balcony.
Eden House has on-site full-service dining and a poolside bar for casual drinks.
Eden House offers a proper restaurant plus a social pool bar—useful for multi-course meals without leaving the property.
H2O Suites lists a bar/lounge and a poolside bar; supplier materials do not publish an on-site full-service restaurant.
H2O Suites provides drinks on-site but you’ll likely rely on nearby Duval Street for full restaurant options.
Eden House is built around tropical courtyards with heated pools, a Jacuzzi, and poolside social spaces.
Eden House’s courtyard pools are a central social feature, good for relaxing and mingling.
H2O Suites has one outdoor pool with poolside bar and sun loungers.
H2O’s pool supports a quieter, adults-only lounge experience close to the rooms and rooftop spaces.
Eden House combines a small on-site wellness offering with easy Old Town nightlife access.
Choose Eden House if you want modest on-site wellness plus quick access to Key West nightlife.
H2O Suites offers fitness facilities and a rooftop terrace; a branded, full-service spa is not published.
H2O suits travelers who prioritize a quiet adults-only stay with fitness options; formal spa services are not published.

Eden House—outdoor Tropical Garden Venue and whole-property buyout options for ceremonies up to 120 guests.

H2O Suites—strict adults-only policy and suite-focused inventory, including rooms with personal plunge pools.

Eden House—Azur Restaurant serves Mediterranean breakfast, lunch, and dinner on-site.

H2O Suites—listed as steps from Duval Street and very close to South Beach and Old Town attractions.
Eden House is family-friendly and welcomes children of any age; H2O Suites is adults-only and does not admit guests under 25.
H2O Suites publishes several room types with a 'Personal Plunge Pool' (e.g., Deluxe Suite, 1 King Bed, Personal Plunge Pool). Eden House does not list private plunge-pool rooms.
Eden House has a full-service on-site restaurant (Azur) plus a poolside Tiki Bar; H2O Suites lists a bar/lounge and poolside bar but no full on-site restaurant in its supplier listing.
Yes—both are located in Old Town Key West within short walks to Duval Street, but H2O Suites is described as steps from Duval while Eden House sits in the historic district a short walk away.
Explore how Eden House stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·