
Eden House
Best for small-group weddings, couples and travelers who want a quiet, garden-centered boutique stay steps from Old Town attractions.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Eden House is a small, locally owned boutique hotel in Old Town Key West organized around tropical courtyards, pools and a Mediterranean restaurant — best for travelers who want a quiet, garden-focused stay near Duval Street. Pier House Resort & Spa is an established Old Town waterfront resort with private beach access and a full-service spa — best for travelers who prioritize a classic resort experience and beach time by Mallory Square.
Updated · about 0.6 km apart

Best for small-group weddings, couples and travelers who want a quiet, garden-centered boutique stay steps from Old Town attractions.

Best for guests who want beachfront access, a larger resort footprint and an on-site full-service spa close to Mallory Square.
When Eden House wins: choose Eden House if you want a small, intimate Old Town property with lush courtyards, a heated pool and a Mediterranean restaurant in a historic building. Its 18 rooms and wedding-garden setup suit couples, small families and guests wanting a quieter base.
When Pier House Resort & Spa wins: pick Pier House if you want direct waterfront and beach access, more on-site facilities (a full-service spa, fitness club and meeting space) and a larger resort feel near Mallory Square and Duval Street.
Bottom line: Eden House is the boutique, garden-forward choice for guests who value intimacy and on-site character; Pier House is the more traditional resort option for those wanting beachfront amenities and a broader range of services.
| Category | Eden House | Pier House Resort & Spa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique, garden-and-courtyard focused | Established waterfront resort with resort-scale amenities |
| Location | Old Town (1015 Fleming St) — short walk to Duval Street and seaport | Old Town waterfront (1 Duval St) — steps from Mallory Square and the seaport |
| Size (rooms) | 18 rooms | 142 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Target audience / age policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must meet a 25+ check-in policy | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool(s) and a hot tub/Jacuzzi, poolside Tiki Bar | One outdoor pool, pool sun loungers and poolside bar |
| Beach access | No private beach on-site | On private beach; beach towels, umbrellas and beach bar available |
| Dining & bars | Azur Restaurant (Mediterranean) + poolside Tiki Bar | On-site restaurant(s), room service (limited hours), beach bar and 2 bars/lounges |
| Wellness / spa | Spa & wellness area (Jacuzzi/sauna, massages offered); fitness center | Full-service spa with massages, body treatments and facials; health club |
| Event options | Outdoor Tropical Garden Venue; weddings up to 120; whole-property buyout possible | Conference space (2,605 sq ft), meeting rooms, wedding services available |
| Accessibility & family features | No elevator; limited on-site parking; bicycles available; children welcome | Wheelchair-accessible public washrooms and paths, pool hoist, accessible parking; self parking (surcharge) |
Eden House sits in Old Town Key West at 1015 Fleming St, within easy walking distance of Duval Street and the historic seaport.
Best if you want a central Old Town base that’s easy to explore on foot or by bike.
Pier House Resort & Spa is on the Old Town waterfront at 1 Duval St, adjacent to Mallory Square and the historic seaport.
Best if you want to be on the water and in the center of Mallory Square activity.
Eden House offers 18 individually styled rooms and suites with names like Deluxe 1 Bedroom Suite and Porch Swing Island Room.
Choose Eden House for individually distinctive rooms and a small-property feel.
Pier House has 142 individually decorated guestrooms across a larger resort property, with a wide range of room types and several oceanfront options.
Pick Pier House if you want more room-type choices and oceanfront options.
Eden House’s on-site dining is centered on Azur Restaurant and the poolside Tiki Bar.
Eden House keeps dining intimate and property-focused with Mediterranean fare and a courtyard bar.
Pier House offers multiple bars and an on-site restaurant, plus limited-room-service hours.
Pier House fits travelers who want resort dining variety and beachside drink options.
Eden House places its heated outdoor pool, hot tub and Tiki Bar inside a tropical courtyard.
Eden House’s courtyard pools suit guests who prefer a quieter, garden pool environment rather than a beach.
Pier House combines an outdoor pool with on-site private beach access and beach amenities.
Pier House is the pick for travelers who want both a pool and direct beach access in Old Town.
Eden House offers a spa & wellness area (sauna, Jacuzzi) and arranges in-room massage treatments.
Eden House works for guests who want simple on-site wellness plus easy access to Old Town nightlife.
Pier House provides a full-service spa plus a health club and easy access to Old Town nightlife and Mallory Square events.
Pier House suits guests who want a fuller spa/resort program and immediate access to waterfront nightlife.

Eden House — Tropical Garden Venue, outdoor ceremonies and whole-property buyout options for intimate events.

Pier House Resort & Spa — on-site private beach, beach bar and beach amenities right on the waterfront.

Pier House Resort & Spa — full-service spa with dedicated treatment spaces and a health club.

Eden House — small (18 rooms), historic building and lush courtyard pools for a quieter Old Town stay.
Pier House is steps from Mallory Square and the waterfront; Eden House is a short walk away but not directly adjacent.
Eden House lists a heated outdoor pool and hot tub; Pier House lists an outdoor pool (heated status not specified in the supplier listing).
Both welcome children. Eden House explicitly states children of any age are allowed (primary guest must meet the property's check-in age policy); Pier House’s listing does not mark it as adults-only.
No — both are in Old Town Key West where many attractions, restaurants and the seaport are within walking or biking distance. Eden House notes cars are not required or recommended; Pier House offers self parking for a surcharge.
Explore how Eden House stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·