
Eden House
Best for intimate garden stays, small weddings, and guests who want a quiet courtyard pool area steps from Old Town attractions.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Eden House is a small, locally owned Old Town Key West boutique hotel set around tropical courtyards, a heated pool, Jacuzzi and a poolside Tiki Bar — good for couples, families and travelers who want a quiet, garden-centered stay. La Concha Key West, Autograph Collection is a larger historic-branded hotel on Duval Street with multiple restaurants, bars and meeting rooms — read this if you want immediate access to Duval’s nightlife and a recognized boutique-brand experience.
Updated · about 1.0 km apart

Best for intimate garden stays, small weddings, and guests who want a quiet courtyard pool area steps from Old Town attractions.

Best for travelers who want to be on Duval Street with branded-boutique amenities, more on-site restaurants/bars, and meeting/event space.
When Eden House wins: choose Eden House if you want a small, historic property with secluded tropical courtyards, a heated pool and an on-site Mediterranean restaurant in a relaxed setting. Its 18 rooms and garden wedding options suit travelers prioritizing privacy and a low-key atmosphere.
When La Concha wins: pick La Concha when you want to be in the thick of Key West nightlife and shops on Duval Street, need more on-site dining and bar options, or require conference/meeting space. Its Autograph Collection positioning and 160 guestrooms make it a recognizable, full-service downtown choice.
Bottom line: Eden House is the quieter, smaller, garden-focused boutique for guests valuing seclusion and wedding/event exclusivity; La Concha is the busier, branded Duval Street property with more rooms, dining outlets and meeting facilities.
| Category | Eden House | La Concha Key West, Autograph Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, historic, courtyard-focused and quiet | Historic-branded, lively, Duval Street-facing |
| Location | 1015 Fleming St — Old Town, short walk to attractions | 430 Duval St — directly on Duval Street, centrally located |
| Size (rooms) | 18 rooms | 160 guestrooms |
| Who can stay | All ages welcome (primary guest must meet check-in age policy) | |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool, Jacuzzi/hot tub, two pool areas noted | One outdoor pool, poolside bar and sun loungers |
| Restaurants & bars | Azur Restaurant (Mediterranean) + poolside Tiki Bar with daily happy hour | Three restaurants including Perla (Caribbean) + two bars/lounges and a poolside bar |
| Spa & wellness | Spa & wellness centre; massages, sauna and hot tub services listed | Not published |
| Known for | Garden weddings, intimate boutique setting and historic building | Landmark Duval Street presence and Autograph Collection boutique branding |
| Meeting / event space | Outdoor Tropical Garden Venue for up to 120 guests; whole-property buyouts possible | 3 meeting rooms, 1,300 sq ft (121 m²) conference space |
| Free Wi‑Fi | Free Wi‑Fi throughout property | |
Eden House sits in Old Town Key West around tropical courtyards, within easy walking distance of Duval Street and the historic seaport.
A quieter Old Town location that still puts you walking distance from key sights.
La Concha occupies a landmark spot directly on Duval Street, placing bars, shops and nightlife at your doorstep.
Choose La Concha to be right on Duval Street for immediate access to the action.
Eden House offers eight room types across 18 rooms, many with island-style layouts and courtyard views.
Rooms feel intimate and integrated with the garden courtyard; size options are limited by the small room count.
La Concha has 160 guestrooms spanning standard rooms to penthouses with balconies and city views.
La Concha offers a wider selection of room types and more capacity for larger parties.
Eden House centers dining around Azur Restaurant and a poolside Tiki Bar with a daily complimentary happy hour.
A focused, on-property dining program with a relaxed Mediterranean restaurant and a social pool bar.
La Concha lists three restaurants (including Perla) plus two bars/lounges and a poolside bar.
More on-site dining options and bars for guests who prefer staying at the hotel for meals and drinks.
Eden House’s signature amenity is its tropical courtyard with a heated pool, hot tub/Jacuzzi and a tiki bar.
The courtyard pool is a quiet, social hub and a main reason many guests choose Eden House.
La Concha offers a single outdoor pool with poolside bar and sun loungers in a central Duval Street location.
La Concha’s pool fits a larger, busier hotel footprint and keeps you close to downtown energy.
Eden House lists a spa & wellness centre with massages, sauna and Jacuzzi services alongside its quiet courtyard vibe.
Eden House is suitable for guests seeking spa treatments and a calmer evening setting.
La Concha emphasizes its downtown location and easy access to Duval Street nightlife rather than a published on-site spa.
Pick La Concha for walk-out access to Key West nightlife; spa services are not clearly published.

Eden House — small property, tropical courtyards, courtyard pool and a relaxed poolside Tiki Bar.

La Concha — sits directly on Duval Street for immediate access to shops, bars and nightlife.

Eden House — outdoor Tropical Garden Venue with capacity for up to 120 guests and whole-property buyout options.

La Concha — three restaurants, multiple bars and 1,300 sq ft of conference/meeting space.
Eden House — its small size, garden courtyards and courtyard pool create a quieter atmosphere than the Duval Street–facing La Concha.
La Concha — located directly on Duval Street so restaurants, bars and shops are steps away.
Yes. Eden House markets an outdoor Tropical Garden Venue for up to 120 guests and offers whole-property buyouts; La Concha provides meeting rooms and conference space (about 1,300 sq ft).
Yes. Both welcome guests of all ages. Eden House notes specific check-in-age requirements for the primary registering guest; La Concha is not adults-only.
Explore how Eden House stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·